Colorado Public Utilities Commission orders Tri-State to "satisfy or answer" exit charge complaint from Delta Montrose Electric
By Joe Smyth | email@example.com | @joesmyth
Delta-Montrose Electric Association (DMEA) took a major step forward in its effort to end its contract with Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association, by filing a formal complaint last week requesting that the Colorado Public Utilities Commission (PUC) "exercise its jurisdiction over Tri-State as a public utility" and "establish an exit charge that is just, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory."
On Monday morning, the Colorado PUC ordered Tri-State "to satisfy the matters in the complaint or to answer the complaint in writing within 20 days." On Monday afternoon, DMEA filed a request that the PUC establish a schedule for the hearings process that would result in a decision by July 11, 2019.
DMEA has sought for years to loosen the restrictions that Tri-State imposes on electric cooperatives, which prevent DMEA and other Colorado co-ops from pursuing more local renewable energy projects. In October, DMEA members voted to give the electric cooperative more financial options to pursue a buyout of its Tri-State contract.
DMEA noted in a press release that it "will partner with Guzman Energy," the same power supplier that supported Kit Carson Electric's $37 million buyout of its contract with Tri-State. Guzman Energy announced today that it is seeking Requests for Proposal for up to 200 megawatts of wind energy and 50 megawatts of solar energy, and has obtained a $200 million capital commitment to help bring on that new renewable energy. Guzman Energy President Chris Riley confirmed that a portion of the 250 megawatts of wind and solar would be used to serve DMEA, if the co-op succeeds in ending its contract with Tri-State.
Colorado utilities announce major new clean energy commitments
DMEA's latest move comes as other electric utilities in Colorado announced major new commitments to clean energy. Last week the state's largest utility, Xcel Energy, became the first major utility in the country to commit to 100% clean energy, and said it also plans to reduce carbon emissions 80 percent by 2030. At the Xcel Energy announcement, Governor-elect Jared Polis said he would like to see Colorado achieve the zero-carbon goal even earlier and wants to work with municipal utilities and rural electric cooperatives to achieve the goal.
Also last week, Platte River Power Authority, which provides power to the municipal utilities of Fort Collins, Loveland, Longmont, and Estes Park, voted to transition to a 100 percent non-carbon energy mix by 2030.
In contrast, Tri-State, which sells power to 18 of the 22 electric cooperatives in Colorado, has not set a target for increasing its use of renewable energy or reducing emissions, and its largest member cooperative, United Power, recently wrote to other co-ops expressing "grave concerns" about Tri-State, including the high cost of power it sells to member co-ops and "Tri-State’s reluctance to embrace additional sources of renewable energy generation due to constraints of its largely fossil fuel generating fleet."
Is membership in Tri-State "voluntary and open" or not?
One key issue raised by the DMEA complaint is the nature of each co-op's membership in Tri-State. Tri-State describes itself as a cooperative, whose members are the 43 electric cooperatives in Colorado, New Mexico, Wyoming, and Nebraska that sell electric power to ratepayers - their members. All cooperatives are supposed to follow seven foundational principles that have been adopted by the International Cooperative Alliance, and first among those is "voluntary and open membership." Tri-State also lists those cooperative principles on its website:
But the electric cooperatives' memberships in Tri-State also include contracts that require each co-op to purchase 95% of their electricity needs from Tri-State until 2050 (or in the case of DMEA, until 2040). That requirement to buy wholesale power helps secure the billions of dollars in debt that Tri-State has taken on to build power plants - so when a co-op leaves Tri-State, it owes an exit charge.
DMEA's complaint details how it has sought information from Tri-State about the way it calculated the charge that DMEA would have to pay to end its contract with Tri-State. That figure has not been published because Tri-State considers it confidential, but DMEA's complaint describes it as "dramatically high," and "vastly disproportionate" to the $37 million exit charge for Kit Carson Electric's departure from Tri-State in 2016. But even without the full details of how Tri-State calculated the exit charge, DMEA argues that it is unreasonable, in part because: "If DMEA's exit charge were proportioned out to all Tri-State cooperatives, the collective exit charge would exceed Tri-State's liabilities by billions of dollars"
The Tri-State board of directors voted in August 2018 against providing more information to DMEA about the way it calculated the exit charge, and also rejected DMEA's appeal of that decision. In response, DMEA requested the involvement of the PUC to help determine a fair exit charge. In that request, DMEA argues that this core cooperative principle of "voluntary and open membership" is "hollow if Tri-State can unilaterally set an exit charge that is unjust, unreasonable and discriminatory."
That section also points to another key issue raised by the DMEA complaint, relevant for co-op directors, staff, and members throughout Colorado:
Do Colorado co-ops put their members' interests first, or their power supplier's?
"DMEA and our Board of Directors have a fiduciary responsibility to serve the best interests of our members to remain a competitive, reliable and cost-effective co-op,” said DMEA Chief Executive Officer Jasen Bronec. “DMEA’s wholesale power costs from Tri-State have been escalating at an unsustainable rate. Tri-State's annual reports show that average member rates have increased 56 percent since 2005, which is more than double the increase in the Consumer Price Index over the same time period. This stands in stark contrast to the overall energy market in which prices have decreased significantly over the same period."
DMEA is focused on the impacts to its own members of the increased cost the co-op pays to Tri-State. But those costs have also been passed on to the nearly 400,000 co-op members that are served by one of the 18 electric cooperatives in Colorado with long-term contracts to buy power from Tri-State. DMEA raised that point in its effort to appeal the Tri-State board of director's August decision:
This article was updated to include the Colorado PUC order to Tri-State to "satisfy or answer" DMEA's complaint, and DMEA's Motion for Procedural Schedule and Request for Hearing en Banc.
DMEA's complaint filed with the Colorado Public Utilities Commission is titled "The Delta-Montrose Electric Association v Tri-State Generation" and is filed under PUC proceeding number 18F-0866E. The full list of documents that DMEA filed with the PUC on December 6 are available below, including the formal complaint and all attachments.
DMEA Formal Complaint
Attachment A TSGT Board Presentation Directors
Attachment B Taos News Article 1
Attachment C TSGT Press Release
Attachment D TSGT Articles and Bylaws
Attachment E Decision No
Attachment F Decision No
Attachment G Taos News Article 2
Attachment H DMEA Board Policy 406 Information Requests
Attachment I TSGT Letter Dated May 8, 2018
Attachment J TSGT Board Decision Dated Aug
Attachment K TSGT Proposed Bylaw Amendments
Attachment L DMEA Appeal of Board Policy 316
Attachment M TSGT Denial of DMEA Appeal
Project Tundra coal carbon project faces delays, higher costs, and departing contractor
Lignite Energy Council shouldn’t be funded by utility ratepayers, Minnesota Attorney General argues
Major co-op supports Biden coal debt relief proposal that NRECA has sought to undermine
Basin Electric faces growing pressure on coal from co-ops, insurers, and banks
Tri-State: Moving a cooperative power provider from coal to clean energy
Tri-State will replace coal plants with a gigawatt of new wind and solar
United Power and La Plata Electric ask Colorado Public Utilities Commission to determine Tri-State exit fee
Colorado Rural Electric Association spent electric cooperatives’ money supporting Republican politicians
Colorado Public Utilities Commissioner questions "whether or not Tri-State has been candid with us"
Rural America could power a renewable economy - but first we need to solve coal debt
Tri-State explores FERC rate regulation to limit state oversight
Poudre Valley Electric sets "80 by 2030" carbon free goal
Guzman Energy proposal would finance retirement of Tri-State coal plants, add 1.2 gigawatts of new wind and solar power
Colorado Public Utilities Commission will oversee Tri-State resource planning
Colorado communities and state Energy Office urge Public Utilities Commission oversight of Tri-State
Reports examine the impacts of Tri-State's high wholesale power costs
Tri-State executive involved with anti-Clean Air Act group since 2005
US Congressional Committee requests details of Tri-State funding to anti-Clean Air Act group
Renewable energy projects stalled in 2018 among Tri-State member co-ops
Second co-op asks Tri-State to pull “Better Together” ads
Tri-State won’t allow co-op members to attend annual meeting
Tri-State expects member co-ops to support bylaw changes at annual meeting
Rocky Mountain Farmers Union calls on Tri-State to adopt flexible contracts and more clean energy
Co-ops in Colorado push for change at Tri-State
Will Municipal Energy Agency of Nebraska remain reliant on coal?
Tri-State ad campaign tells co-ops they’re “better together”
La Plata Electric concerned Tri-State debt will lead to higher rates
Colorado Public Utilities Commission asserts jurisdiction over Tri-State
More Colorado co-ops announce clean energy goals
Ski industry climate change efforts shift to electric utilities and their regulators
Public Utilities Commission rejects Tri-State motion to exclude Colorado Energy Office from exit charge case
Tri-State claims that co-ops "have intervened on Tri-State's behalf at the PUC” don’t add up
Colorado state legislators urge Public Utilities Commission to determine Tri-State exit charge
United Power says Tri-State policies are turning away large customers
Next PUC Commissioner John Gavan "consensus choice" of Governors Hickenlooper and Polis
Tri-State policy change discourages battery projects in rural Colorado and New Mexico
Colorado Public Utilities Commission orders Tri-State to "satisfy or answer" exit charge complaint from Delta Montrose Electric
United Power seeks solutions to "increasingly outmoded G&T business models"
Clean Energy Means Business Summit highlights renewable energy opportunities and challenges in rural Colorado
Governor-elect Jared Polis says moving Colorado toward more renewable energy will be a top priority
Electric cooperative officials discuss cheap renewable energy and an “eroding monopoly”
Delta Montrose Electric members vote for new financing options, supporting a potential buyout of Tri-State contract
Poudre Valley Electric requests Tri-State policy changes and fuel mix study
Holy Cross Energy plans to shift away from coal, aiming for 70% renewable energy
What do corporate renewable energy commitments mean for electric utilities?
Colorado Energy Plan approval will mean new renewable energy investments in rural Colorado
Report: Tri-State could save $600 million by shifting from coal to renewable energy
Delta Montrose Electric seeks new financing options to end contract with Tri-State
Wind energy jobs in rural Colorado attract bipartisan support
Colorado Energy Plan analysis shows switching from coal to renewable energy will boost jobs and local tax revenue
Poudre Valley Electric and Xcel Energy Colorado President win national awards from Smart Electric Power Alliance
Latest coal plant subsidy proposal could hit electricity bills in the West
Moody’s report: “High quality renewable resources” could help Tri-State and Basin Electric navigate rising carbon transition risks
Senator Heinrich highlights “frustrations in New Mexico” with Tri-State’s limits on local solar
Moody’s report shows Tri-State’s coal plants are more expensive than new renewable energy
Tri-State’s limits on local energy development are a growing problem for co-op members
Governor Hickenlooper discusses Tri-State at the Climate Leadership Conference
Bids for Xcel’s Colorado Energy Plan include a proposal for the world’s largest battery
New wind and solar power in Colorado is now cheaper than existing coal plants
Companies' 100% renewable energy goals are getting results in Colorado
What does cheap solar mean for electric cooperatives?
Colorado towns and cities are helping push utilities to embrace renewable energy
How are electric cooperatives navigating the transition from coal to cheap clean energy?
Blocked from building more solar projects, United Power shifts to community batteries
Economic reality sets in for Tri-State efforts to expand the Holcomb coal plant
Solar projects in the works in Grand and Jackson counties
Mountain Parks Electric grapples with solar